Each day (except for Christmas, New Year’s Eve, and January 9th), I will reveal one cigar per day of what I consider the thirty best cigars reviewed over a 12-month period on Cigar Coop. On January 10th, 2022 both the #1 and #2 cigars will be unveiled. Most of the criteria will be the same as the previous year.
One important designation is that the Cigar Coop team has grown substantially, and this list doesn’t speak for the team. Several team members have their own brands and work on their own lists, so this year the list will be designated as Coop’s List. This list and process has matured over the years and it would take many other steps to extend it to a team list. That is an option for the future that could be considered. It was too soon to do it now.
The month of November is the time when the list is constructed. In past years, cigars 91 points and over that met the eligibility criteria were considered. This year was tougher in that there were not 30 cigars that scored over 91 points, so the threshold has been lowered to 90 points. There were 48 cigars out of 163 that were reviewed that met the eligibility criteria. This means 18 of those cigars will neither be making the list, nor getting honorable mentions.
In an effort to be transparent, this is how things work:
- The 48 cigars are ranked from 1 to 48 based on how they did from the reviews throughout a one-year period on Cigar Coop ending October 31st, 2021. This ranking is done by me.
- Cigars that scored 91 or over clinch a spot in the finals. There are a total of 23 cigars in this category.
- The remaining 25 cigars had a score of 90 points. These are referred to as “Bubble Cigars”.
- The top ten ranked bubble cigars from the review cycle of the cigar year move on to the finals, reducing the pool of cigars from 48 to 33.
- The cigar “finalists” are re-smoked by me over a period of time ending in early December.
- After each re-smoke, a cigar may move up or down from its original position. This will adjust positions of the original ranking.
- It’s possible that no cigar in the finals will clinch a spot in the Top 30. Although highly unlikely, it’s possible the #1 cigar ranked falls out of the Top 30 when the ranking is adjusted – and vice versa. When the adjusted list is finalized, three cigars will fall off.
There is no process or criteria that is perfect. Some end of the year lists are created for fun, but my goal here was to build a process that was not agile, and taken with a high level of seriousness.
One thing that I will be adding is a short video/audio component (under five minutes)for each of the cigars on the list in addition to the written component. Cigar Coop never uses click bait when we announce the cigar. The cigar that lands in a position is clearly denoted in the title, and if you are interested you can read/listen/watch it to learn more.
Some have suggested end of the year lists have worn out their welcome. For Cigar Coop, there is no evidence of such a trend and it has grown every year since the concept was introduced in 2010.
I hope you enjoy the journey to #1 this year!