Cigar Scores – 2012 to 2015

The scoring system was introduced to Cigar Coop in 2012. We have many cigars that have been assessed and not scored. Throughout the year, the goal is to assess a numeric score to many of the cigars we have assessed in previous years.

Cigar Coop uses a “Cigar Year” beginning the day after Thanksgiving and ending on Thanksgiving the following calendar year. Cigars are listed under the year of when our assessment was published and not when the cigar was released.

* Denotes Oasis Rating given

* Padron 50th Anniversary Maduro (The Hammer) (1/14/15)

* Avo Limited Edition 2010 (Avo LE10) (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (2/6/15)
* Cubanacan HR Sublime (12/8/14)
* Debonaire 33rd Maduro (10/12/15)
Illusione ~eccj~ 20th (4/9/15)
Matilde Oscura Toro Bravo (10/28/15)
Quesada Reserva Privada Robusto (4/6/15)

94
Avo Limited Edition 2011 85th Anniversary (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (1/30/15)
Don Reynaldo Corona De Luxe by Warped Cigars (12/17/14)
Flor de Selva Maduro Toro by Maya Selva Cigars (10/8/15)
Padron 50th Anniversary Natural (11/17/15)

93
1502 Emerald Corona (2/23/15)
Avo Limited Edition 2007 (Avo LE07) (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (3/22/15)
Avo Limited Edition 2013 – The Dominant 13th (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (12/15/14)
Avo Limited Edition 2014 (Avo 88) (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (9/11/15)
Avo Limited Edition Improvisation Series – Avo Classic Covers 2015 (4/23/15)
Camacho American Barrel-Aged Toro (6/17/15)
Casa Magna Domus Magnus II Trajan by Quesada Cigars (1/13/15)
D’Crossier Selection 512 Lancero (10/25/15)
Davidoff Escurio Robusto (7/14/15)
Davidoff Nicaragua Diadema Fina (2/4/15)
Debonaire Maduro Belicoso (5/4/15)
Falto 20th Aniversario Los Procesos (6/8/15)
Felipe Gregorio Art of Power Lord Byron (2015 Edition) (10/4/15)
Fratello Bianco I (6/29/15)
Indian Motorcycle Habano Robusto (11/4/15)
J. Grotto Anniversary P555 by Ocean State Cigars (11/28/14)
La Boheme Pittore by Boutique Blends Cigars (8/28/15)
La Colonia Miami Torpedo (2/5/15)
Las Cumbres Tabaco Senorial Maduro Natural Robusto Digno by Jose Blanco (11/5/15)
LUJ Morpheus Anniversary #4 Maduro Box Pressed (4/26/15)
LUJ Morpheus Anniversary #4 Belicoso (5/31/15)
My Father Oro de Nicaragua Toro (12/29/14)
Padron Family Reserve No. 85 Maduro (12/12/14)
Pepper Cream Soda Robusto (Supreme Cream) by Bellatto / Caldwell / Sears (2/10/15)
Quesada Seleccion Espana Petit Belicoso (2/18/15)
Recluse Amadeus Habano Reserva Toro (8/19/15)
RoMa Craft Tobac Aquitaine Venus (1/29/15)
RoMa Craft Tobac Neanderthal HN (9/25/15)
Senorial 65th Anniversary Perfecto Elegance by Las Cumbres Tabaco (12/22/14)
Viva Republica Propaganda Five and a Half Truth (11/30/14)

92

Aging Room Bin No. 1 D Major by Boutique Blends Cigars (10/14/15)
A.J. Fernandez Enclave Robusto (8/11/15)
A.J. Fernandez New World Connecticut Corona Gorda (10/23/15)
A.J. Fernandez New World Connecticut Toro (5/25/15)
The Alibi by Espinosa Cigars (Part of the Backroom Series) (1/27/15)
Asylum 33 5 1/2 x 46 (2015) (9/21/15)
Avo 75th Anniversary (Avo Limited Edition 2001) (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (8/16/15)
Avo Classic Covers Volume 2 (Part of the Avo Improvisation Series) (10/19/15)
Avo Limited Edition 2003 – Avo 77 (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (5/6/15)
The Corona Project Vol. 1 by Rodrigo Cigars (3/6/15)
Davidoff Golf Limited Masters Edition 2015 Robusto (4/7/15)
Davidoff Winston Churchill Toro (9/4/15)
Agile Cigar Review: Eiroa Robusto by CLE Cigars
Ezra Zion FHK Truth (12/31/14)
Flor de D’Crossier Selection No. 512 Hermosos No. 2 by D’Crossier Cigars (6/22/15)
Flor del Valle Sky Flower by Warped Cigars (6/15/15)
Flor de Selva Tempo Maduro by Maya Selva Cigars (12/21/14)
Flores y Rodriguez 10th Anniversary Reserva Limitada Robusto by PDR Cigars (11/2/15)
Headlines 1st Edition Page 3 (5/10/15)
Illusione Pactum (Part of the Smoke Inn MicroBlend Series) (1/14/15)
Imperio Cubano Miami Natural by Antillian Cigar Corporation (9/1/15)
Indian Motorcycle Maduro Toro (11/19/15)
Kristoff Classic Reserva Toro (10/6/15)
La Aurora Cien Anos Preferidos (Havana Cigar Club Edition) (6/24/15)
La Aurora Cien Anos Lancero Cameroon (3/30/15)
La Bohème Encantador Fenice by Boutique Blends Cigars (11/20/15)
Matilde Renacer Robusto (3/26/15)
MBombay Kesara Toro (3/18/15)
MBombay Mora No. 4 (7/8/15)
My Father Oro de Nicaragua Perfecto (5/1/15)
Nat Sherman Panamericana Cervantes (TAA Exclusive) (5/14/15)
Nomad S-307 Robusto (1/16/14)
Quesada Seleccion Espana Fabulosos (3/15/15)
The Rake Cut by MoyaRuiz Cigars (6/25/15)
Roberto P. Duran Signature Santo Cardenas Edition (10/5/15)
Rocky Patel Decade Cameroon Robusto (10/16/15)
Rocky Patel Prohibition San Andres (2/25/15)
Rocky Patel Twentieth Anniversary Lancero (11/26/15)
Room 101 Namakubi Ecuador Ranfla (1/23/15)
Saga Blend No 7 Perfecto (9/30/15)
Senor Rio Anejo Toro (1/18/15)
San Lotano – The Bull Robusto by A.J. Fernandez Cigars (4/5/15)
Sosa Half Century (10/18/15)
Tatuaje Anarchy 2015 (9/10/15)
Tatuaje The Jackal (8/27/15)
The Griffin’s Special Edition 2015 Club Series III (6/15/15)
Viaje Holiday Blend 2014 (5/22/15)
Viva Republica Advanced Warfare Petit (9/8/15)
Vivalo Serie Exclusivo Robusto Grande (11/8/15)

91

A.J. Fernandez New World Brute (5/13/15)
Asylum Dragon’s Milk (12/26/14)
Avo Limited Edition 2004 – Avo Legacy (Avo LE04) (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (4/29/15)
Black Label Trading Company Deliverance Nocturne Salomon Snub Nose (9/20/15)
Bold by Nish Patel Robusto (11/16/15)
Casa Fernandez Aganorsa Leaf Maduro Delire (5/29/15)
Casa Fernandez Arsenio Serie Oro Robusto (12/16/14)
Casa Magna D. Magnus II TAA Exclusive Hadrian (9/17/15)
CAO Amazon Basin (4/30/15)
CAO Pilon Robusto (9/29/15)
Camacho Ecuador Toro (5/8/15)
Cohiba Nicaragua N50 En Crystale (3/4/15)
Crux du Connoisseur No. 2 (10/7/15)
Drew Estate Norteno Edicion Limitada Churchill (10/15/15)
E.P. Carrillo Perez-Carrillo La Historia E-III (12/23/14)
EPM Larceny by Eddie Ortega (5/19/15)
Espada by Montecristo Estoque (11/23/15)
Espinosa Laranja Reserva Caixa (10/21/15)
Esteban Carreras Black Cross Corona (8/26/15)
Flor de Selva Connecticut Toro by Maya Selva Cigars (7/6/15)
Freyja Valhalla Robusto by Las Cumbres Tabaco (10/22/15)
Illusione ~68~ Maduro (6/19/15)
Imperio Cubano Miami Maduro Robusto by Antillian Cigar Corporation (7/7/15)
Jailbreak by Viva Republica (2/16/15)
La Mission du L’Atelier 1959 (11/25/15)
La Aurora Preferidos Diamond Corona Especiales (12/2/14)
La Aroma de Cuba Noblesse 2014 by Ashton Cigars (8/21/15)
La Colmena Amado No. 36 by Warped Cigars (3/9/15)
La Flor Dominicana 1994 Tango (10/30/15)
La Flor Dominicana TCKFA M Collector’s Edition 2014 (2/9/15)
La Flor Dominicana TAA 47 (5/26/15)
La Hacienda Superiores by Warped Cigars (9/22/15)
Las Cumbres Tabaco Senorial Belicoso No. 2 by Jose Blanco (7/3/15)
LH Colorado Robusto (10/11/15)
LUJ Kuro Perfecto (11/15/15)
LUJ Serengeti Toro (6/21/15)
Macanudo Estate Reserve 2015 No. 9 (10/27/15)
Matilde Renacer Lancero (11/13/15)
Montecristo 80th Anniversary No. 2 by Altadis USA (10/13/15)
Nomad C-276 Robusto (3/31/15)
Nomad Therapy Maduro Toro (9/23/15)
Paul Stulac Red Screaming Sun Mr. Brown (12/28/14)
The Chinese Finger Trap by MoyaRuiz Cigars (9/7/15)
The Pope of Greenwich Village By Drew Estate (Part of the Smoke Inn MicroBlend Series)
Quesada Seleccion Espana Beli-Lance (3/23/15)
Regius Limited Edition Corona Gorda Cuban Box Press (11/10/15)
Romeo by Romeo y Julieta Aging Room Small Batch F25 Capriccio (7/1/15)
Room 101 Uncle Lee (9/28/15)
Sensei’s Sensational Sarsaparilla by Espinosa Cigars (2/12/15)
Tatuaje 10th Anniversary Belle Encre Reserva (4/10/15)
The Chinese Finger Trap by MoyaRuiz Cigars (9/7/15)
Tortuga 215 Reserva Connecticut Regios by Legacy Brands (9/6/15)
Untamed Extreme Robusto by La Aurora (10/26/15)
Viaje Super Shot Criollo 2015 12 Gauge (3/20/15)
Viaje Throw Down Fed Head (6/16/15)
Viaje Zombie Antidote 2015 (5/15/15)
Viaje Zombie Super Shot 2015 (6/5/15)


90

Alec Bradley Coyol Toro (3/16/15)
Arturo Fuente Casa Cuba Doble Cuatro (10/29/15)
Avo Limited Edition 2002 – Avo 22 (American) (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (6/11/15)
Avo Limited Edition 2009 Companero (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (2/13/15)
Avo XO Legato (10/2/15)
Azan Maduro Natural Robusto Extra by Roberto P. Duran Cigars (5/21/15)
Black Label Trading Company Deliverance Corona (12/7/14)
Cesar Espinal Habano No. 3 (5/24/15)
Cubanacan Soneros Maduro Corona Gorda (2/3/15)
Cumpay Robusto by Maya Selva Cigars (4/14/15)
Debonaire First Degree (Habano) (11/12/15)
Dram Cask No. 1 Toro by C & C Cigars (1/26/15)
Dram Cask No.2 Toro by C & C Cigars (2/17/15)
Drew Estate Undercrown Shade Gran Toro (11/18/15)
Espinosa Laranja Reserva Corona Gorda (12/9/14)
Felipe Gregorio Pelo de Oro Robusto Gordo (2014) (1/25/15)
Futuro Seleccion 109 (11/11/15)
Gran Habano Gran Reserva #5 2011 Gran Robusto (7/2/15)
Hammer + Sickle Trademark Series Churchill (Formerly Hammer + Sickle Icon Series) (5/3/15)
Illusione Singulare EL 2014 Anunnaki (10/20/15)
Illusione Ultra OP No. 7 (10/9/15)
Inca Secret Blend Tambo (5/17/15)
Kuuts Nicaraguan Blend Toro (2/15/15)
La Aurora Puro Vintage 2006 Edicion Limitada 111 Aniversario (6/9/15)
La Palina Black Label Robusto (12/11/14)
La Rosa de Sandiego Connecticut Toro Gordo (8/30/15)
Lavida Habana (LH) Maduro LH52 (1/11/15)
Nat Sherman 85th Anniversary (11/3/15)
Nestor Miranda Collection One Life Edition Danno Maduro (2015) (6/18/15)
Ortega Larceny by Sean Williams (6/3/15)
Padron 1926 Serie No. 47 Natural (TAA Exclusive) (10/1/15)
Partagas 1845 Extra Fuerte Double Corona (11/6/15)
Perdomo Double Aged 12 Year Vintage Connecticut Robusto (3/2/15)
Protocol Corona Gorda by Cubariqueno Cigar Company (8/23/15)
Quesada Keg (1/28/15)
Quesada Oktoberfest 2015 Das Brauhaus (9/3/15)
Quesada Oktoberfest Dunkel (2/27/15)
Room 101 Ichiban Ranfla (Exclusive to Doc James Cigars) (6/23/15)
Saga Golden Age Toro (4/27/15)
Southern Draw Firethorn Robusto (2/8/15)
Swag Black VIP by Boutique Blends Cigars (1/6/15)
Tatuaje Avion 13 FF (9/18/15)
Viaje Farmer Bill Hatchet Handle (2014) (1/22/15)
Viaje Summerfest 2015 (8/18/15)
Viaje Throw Down Dojonation (6/30/15)
Viaje TNT 2015 (8/31/15)
Viaje White Label Project (WLP) PL TB#7 (3/19/15)
Viva Republica Edicion Limitada Culebra (3/17/15)
Wilson Adams Mr. Wilson (9/27/15)
Wilson Adams Sumatra No. 4 (3/8/15)

89

1502 Ruby Corona (3/27/15)
Aged Selects Habano Oscuro Churchill (4/19/15)
Aged Selects Maduro Toro Grande (2/1/15)
Alec Bradley Sanctum Robusto (6/12/15)
Avo Limited Edition 2006 – Avo 80th (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (4/3/15)
Avo Limited Edition 2008 Tesoro (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (3/13/15)
Avo Limited Edition 2012 La Trompeta (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (1/23/15)
Avo Syncro Nicaragua Robusto (8/24/15)
The Buckingham by Crowned Heads (12/4/14)
Caldwell The Last Tsar Belicoso (8/17/15)
CAO Colombia Vallenato (12/18/14)
Crux Passport Half Corona (4/8/15)
Cubanacan Habano Rothschild (3/24/15)
Cuenca 5 Anniversary Toro (2/26/15)
Davidoff Year of the Monkey Limited Edition 2016 (11/9/15)
E.P. Carrillo Short Run 2015 Vencedores (5/5/15)
Fratello Boxer (4/21/15)
Fratello H-Town Lancero (3/11/15)
Garofalo Robusto (3/12/15)
Guayacan Sabor de Esteli Maduro Gordo (5/12/15)
Hoyo de Monterrey Edicion de Cumpleanos 150 (4/13/15)
KILO Toro by United Cigar (9/13/15)
La Flor Dominicana 1994 Rumba (1/12/15)
Lost & Found Racks on Racks (5/18/15)
Montecristo Grupo de Maestros Private Batch by Altadis USA (2/2/15)
Montecristo White Vintage Connecticut Double Corona (8/25/15)
Oliva Serie V Maduro Especial 2012 (4/24/15)
Punch Rare Corojo El Diablo 2015 (5/7/15)
Rocky Patel Prohibition Broadleaf (1/21/15)
Senor Andre’s Chicharrones Bold (Maduro) by Viaje (9/15/15)
Senor Andre’s Chicharrones Original (Corojo) by Viaje (3/29/15)
Senor Andre’s Chicharrones Spicy (Criollo) by Viaje (4/28/15)
Untamed by La Aurora Robusto (12/5/14)
VegaFina Nicaragua Robusto (1/8/15)
Viaje Stuffed Turkey White Meat 2014 (12/19/14)

88
1875 by Romeo y Julieta Tres (3/25/15)
Camacho Liberty 2015 (7/4/15)
Gurkha Heritage Toro (9/24/15)
Hammer + Sickle Berlin Wall Series Toro (2/22/15)
Nestor Miranda Collection Habano Robusto (1/19/15)
Nestor Miranda Collection One Life Edition Danno Habano (2015) (9/13/15)
Padron Damaso No. 12 (11/24/15)
Tatuaje TAA 2014 (1/2/15)
Viaje Stuffed Turkey Dark Meat 2014 (12/10/14)

87
Arturo Fuente Unnamed Reserve 2014 (4/20/15)
Avo 25th Anniversary Edition (Part of Avo’s Greatest Hits Sampler) (12/25/14)
CAO Nasty Nutcracker (12/24/14)
Monte Pascoal Double Corona (2015) (11/22/15)

86
Por Larranaga TAA En Cedro by Altadis USA (9/9/15)

85
Balmoral Anejo XO Rothschild Masivo by Royal Agio Cigars (9/16/15)

94

91

1502 Emerald Perfecto (1/10/14)
2006 Vintage Stout Corona by Bellatto / Caldwell / Sears (8/10/14)
Aging Room M20 ffortissimo by Boutique Blends Cigars (10/27/14)
Alec Bradley Fine and Rare 2012 (BR1213) (11/12/14 – Reassessment)
Avo 80th (Avo LE 2006)  (3/22/14 – Reassessment)
Black Label Trading Company Morphine (6/11/14)
Brun del Re Colonial (5/18/14)
Caldwell Seleccion Junior Varsity Sevillana Magnum (9/11/14)
Casino Gold H.R.S. by Royal Gold Cigars (3/6/14)
Cuellar Connecticut Krēmē by Villiger Cigars (6/26/14)
Cuenca 5 Anniversary Robusto (4/18/14)
D’Crossier L’Forte Robusto (11/23/14)
Debonaire First Degree (5/27/14)
EIROA CBT Maduro by CLE Cigars (8/18/14)
E.P. Carrillo Cabinet Robusto (11/17/14)
E.P. Carrillo Edicion Limitada 2013 (1/13/14)
E-Stunner by E.P. Carrillo (12/13/13)
Ezra Zion Tantrum (Reassessment) (1/10/14)
El Cedro (Corona Gorda) (1/26/14)
El Mayimbe (2013) by A.J. Fernandez Cigars (1/3/14)
Felipe Gregorio Power 2014 Triple R (10/16/14)
Hammer + Sickle Berlin Wall Series Celebration Short Corona (11/9/14)
JFR XT Corojo 654 XT by Casa Fernandez (10/9/14)
Joya Red Robusto by Joya de Nicaragua (11/7/14)
Leaf by Oscar Maduro (12/29/13)
Litto Gomez Diez Small Batch No. 5 by La Flor Dominicana (12/23/13)
Leccia Luchador El Hombre by Leccia Tobacco (10/31/14)
My Father TAA Exclusive 2014 (5/26/14)
Nat Sherman Epoca Selection Prince (11/6/14)
Neya Classic Canonazo by Roberto P. Duran Cigars (11/2/14)
Nomad Connecticut Fuerte (5/9/14)
Ortega Wild Bunch 2013 Warrior Joe Bushmaster (12/10/13)
Padron 1964 Anniversary Belicoso TAA Exclusive Natural (2014) (10/23/14)
Padron Family Reserve No. 50 Natural (11/24/14)
Placeres Reserva (3/9/14)
Project 7 by Noel Rojas (6/18/14)
Rocky Patel Royale Robusto (2/28/14)
Room 101 Master Collection Two Roxxo (4/6/14)
Room 101 Serie HN (Honduras) (Reassessment) (9/12/14)
San Lotano Oval Habano Limited Edition Pigskin Super Smoke Figurado XLVIII (2/5/14)
Tatuaje Avion 13 Reserva (12/12/13)
Tatuaje 10th Anniversary Belle Encre Reserva (4/17/14)
Tatuaje Lil’ Drac (Assessment Update) (6/27/14)
Tatuaje Tattoo (2014) Caballero (5/13/14)
Tatuaje Tiff (Part of the Pudgy Monsters Series) (8/1/14)
VegaFina Sumum Edicion Especial 2010 Toro (2014 Release) by Altadis USA (2/14/14)
Viaje Exclusivo Atlantic Cigar Company 15th Anniversary Lancero (2011 Release) (4/21/14)
Zino Platinum Z-Class Series (2/7/14)

90

89

93
601 La Bomba Maduro Warhead by Espinosa Cigars (11/27/13)
AFR-75 by PDR Cigars (11/8/13)
Aging Room Maduro (9/5/13)
Casa Fernandez Miami Reserva Maduro (9/24/13)
Casa Magna Domus Magnus (12/25/12)
Casa Magna Domus Magnus II (5/6/13)
Casa Miranda Chapter One by Miami Cigar and Company (5/3/13)
Cuenca 5 Anniversary (1/31/13)
D’Crossier Diplomacy Series Robusto (11/3/13)
Ezra Zion Tantrum (6/24/13)
Fonseca TAA Signature Series (4/10/13)
Guillermo Leon Signature by La Aurora (2/26/13)
L’Atelier LAT46 Selection Speciale (5/20/13)
L’Atelier (LAT52) (9/6/13 – Reassessment)
L’Atelier Maduro (MAD54) (8/14/13)
La Aurora Preferidos 1903 Edition Diamond (6/11/13)
La Flor Dominican Pipe and Pint 15th Anniversary (4/11/13)
La Palina Collection Mr. Sam (8/30/13)
Mike Ditka Kickoff Series – The Player by Camacho Cigars (5/30/13)
My Father Commemorative 911 Limited Edition 2012 Habano Maduro (12/2/12)
Nestor Miranda 70th LE Dominican (4/5/13)
Nestor Miranda Special Selection Danno 2012 (11/23/12)
Ortega Wild Bunch 2013 – Island Jim WaHoo (3/10/13)
Ortega Wild Bunch 2013 – Iron Mike I-Beam (2/19/13)
Paul Gamirian Symphony 20 Limited Edition Salomones (10/6/13)
Recluse Draconian Sidewinder #1 by Iconic Leaf Cigar Company (11/10/13)
Reinado Grand Empire Reserve Petit Lancero (11/6/13)
Rocky Patel II-XXVI (4/22/13)
Rocky Patel Fifteenth Anniversary 6 x 60 (7/11/13)
Room 101 Big Delicioius (7/21/13)
Tatuaje 10th Anniversary Grand Chasseur TAA 2013 (10/15/13)
Tres Reynas (3 Reynas) 2012 (Reassessment – 7/16/13)
Viaje Holiday Blend 2012 Candy Cane (12/11/12)
Viva Republica Guerilla Warfare (10/22/13)

92
262 Revere Lonsdale (J. Shepherd Retail Exclusive) (8/27/13)
601 Blue Label Maduro (6/2/13)
Alec Bradley Black Market (1/14/13)
Alec Bradley Nica Puro (4/18/13)
Avo Limited Edition 2009 Companero (Avo LE 09) (3/22/13)
Camacho Criollo (2013) (9/10/13)
CRAFT 2013 – La Campana de Panama Soberana by RoMa Craft Tobac (10/23/13)
El Primer Mundo Epifania (4/14/13)
Emilio AF2 (2/27/13)
E.P. Carrillo NWC Short Run 2012 (4/28/13)
Espinosa Maduro (5/10/13)
Flor de las Antillas Toro Grande (Retail Exclusive to Binny’s Beverage Depot) (7/30/13)
Fratello by Fratello Cigars (9/4/13)
Heisenberg by Quesada (2/20/13)
Humo Jaguar by Miami Cigar and Company (1/18/13)
Kristoff Galerones DR4 (10/17/13)
Kristoff Galerones Sentido (11/5/13)
L’Atelier (1/8/13)
La Flor Dominicana Chapter One (8/26/13)
La Palina Maduro (1/9/13)
Lou Rod by Lou Rodriguez Cigars (9/20/13)
My Father Limited Edition 2011 (12/30/12)
My Father Limited Edition 2012 (12/28/12)
My Uzi Weighs a Ton Digital Son 6 (MUWAT DS-6) (3/13/13)
Nat Sherman 1930 Collection (7/24/13)
Ora Vivo Armand Assante
Ortega Wild Bunch 2013 – Big Bad John “Jackhammer” (1/22/13)
Ortega Wild Bunch 2013 Wild Bill “Cheroot” (8/15/13)
Quesada Oktoberfest Kaiser Ludwig 2012 (6/5/13)
Reinado Grand Empire Reserve Toro (10/3/13)
RoMa Craft Intemperance BA XXI (2/8/13)
RoMa Craft Fomorian (3/24/13)
Room 101 San Andres (3/6/13 – Reassessment)
Tatuaje Black Label Lancero (Tatuaje Private Reserve Lancero) (2/3/13)
Tatuaje Noellas Reserva 2013 (5/29/13)
Torano Vault (1/6/13)
Viaje Exclusivo Super Lance (6/7/13)
Viaje Satori Edicion Limitada 2012 (12/21/12)
Viaje Summerfest 2013 (8/25/13)
Viaje White Label Project (WLP) St. Patrick’s Day Candela 2011 (3/17/13)
Viaje White Label Project (WLP) Super Shot 12 Gauge (2012) (5/27/13)

91
A. Flores Gran Reserva by PDR Cigars (9/25/13)
AKA Solace (10/18/13)
Alec Bradley Fine and Rare HJ10-i Second Issue (Alec Bradley Fine and Rare 2013) (9/26/13)
Alec Bradley Maxx Brazil (1/16/13)
Azan White Premium by Roberto Duran Cigars (8/13/13)
Black Warrior – Reagan by R&R Cigars
BSB No. 1 by Bernie Parent (12/22/12)
Casa Fernandez Aganorsa Leaf Maduro Illustre (11/19/13)
Davidoff Nicaragua (Robusto) (8/16/13)
Davidoff of Geneva 25th Anniversary (10/21/13)
Ditka Throwback by Camacho Cigars (6/19/13)
Dunhill Aged Reserva Especial 2003 (3/15/13)
East India Trading Company Red Witch Double Fuerte (3/14/13)
“E” by BOTL LLC (5/31/13)
EH Pasion by Edgar Hoill Cigars (2/21/13)
E.P. Carrillo Edicion Limitada 2012 (12/4/12)
Espinosa Robusto (12/23/12)
Fonseca Cubano Exclusivo (3/30/13)
Four Kicks Mule Kick Limited Edition 2012 (12/17/12)
Frank Herrera Biography (5/12/13)
Gurkha 125th Anniversary (2/25/13)
Illusione Rothchildes (3/28/13)
J. Grotto Reserva Lancero by Ocean State Cigars (7/15/13)
J. Grotto Silk by Ocean State Cigars (1/10/13)
Juan Lopez (2013) by Altadis USA (9/30/13)
La Duena No 13 (6/25/13)
La Flor Dominicana Double Press Maduro (TAA Edition) (8/19/13)
La Flor Dominicana Mystery Cigar (3/25/13)
La Flor Dominicana Oro Natural (12/7/12)
La Jugada Prieto by Moya Ruiz Cigars (7/28/13)
Leccia Tobacco Black (5/28/13)
Leccia Tobacco White (5/7/13)
Lou Rodriguez MF (3/5/13)
Nomad S-307 (11/21/13)
Ortega Wild Bunch 2013 Honest Abe “Ringmaster” (6/18/13)
Recluse Kanu #1 by Iconic Leaf Cigar Company (11/24/13)
Robusto by Valentia (10/20/13)
Rocky Patel Royale (RP Royale) (9/11/13)
Room 101 Daruma – Papi Chulo (11/29/12)
Room 101 Namakubi Ecuador (3/27/13)
Room 101 Serie HN (Honduras) (9/12/13)
Senor Solomon Maduro (3/26/13)
Swag SoBE Edition (7/18/13)
Tatuaje Avion 13 FF (10/7/13)
Tatuaje Exclusive Series Tobacco Plaza DD (Original Release) (4/25/13)
Viaje 5th Anniversary (4/30/13 – Reassessment)
Viaje Holiday Blend 2012 (12/13/12)
Viaje White Label Project (WLP) St. Patrick’s Day Candela 2013 (3/21/13)
Viaje White Label Project (WLP) Stuffed Turkey 2012 Dark Meat (12/15/12)
Zino Platinum Collector’s Series 2013 – The Make of New York (6/10/13)

90
601 La Bomba by Espinosa Cigars (12/29/12)
A. Flores Gran Reserva Half Corona by PDR Cigars (10/11/13)
Alec Bradley Black Market Filthy Hooligan (3/7/13)
Alec Bradley New York (5/2/13)
Arandoza Blue Label (5/26/13)
Asylum 13 (1/23/13)
Bold by Nish Patel (11/4/13)
Camacho Diploma (2013) (10/16/13)
D’Crossier Imperium Class Vintage Trabuco  (9/15/13)
Davidoff Golden Band Awards 2012 (10/9/13)
Davidoff Masters Edition 2013 Club House Toro (6/12/13)
Dona Flor Puro Mata Fina (12/26/12)
Dona Flor Seleção (2/10/12)
E.P. Carrillo Edicion Limitada 2011 – Dark Rituals (1/11/13)
East India Trading Company Red Witch (3/4/13)
East India Trading Company Wicked Indie Double Fuerte (4/7/13)
Epicurean Gonzo Vintage 2007 (10/13/13)
Ezra Zion Honor Series Reagan (1/19/13)
La Aurora 107 Maduro (5/24/13)
La Flor Dominicana Colorado Oscuro 2013 (9/13/13)
La Flor Dominicana Doomsday 2012 Meaner Digger (1/15/13)
La Flor Dominicana Factory Press Limitado 2013 (9/26/13)
La Gloria Cubana Serie R Esteli (10/28/13)
La Hermandad by Primer Mundo Cigars (4/29/13)
Liga Privada Unico Serie Papas Fritas (1/7/13)
Lou Rodriguez Habano-Rosado (2/17/13)
Macanudo Vintage 1997 Maduro (1/30/13)
Nat Sherman Timeless Collection (Nicaraguan) (2/6/13)
Nica Rustica El Brujito by Drew Estate (11/25/13)
Nording 50th Anniversary by Rocky Patel (12/20/12)
Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro (2013) (8/8/13)
Ortega Wild Bunch 2013 Dandy McCoy “Empire State” (5/23/13)
Ortega Wild Bunch 2013 Fast Eddie Eight-Ball (9/16/13)
Padilla Reserva Maduro (4/3/13)
Raices Cubanas 1941 by Alec Bradley (11/18/13)
Surrogates Crystal Baller (2/5/13)
VegaFina Master 2012 (12/8/12)
VegaFina Sumum Edicion Especial 2012 by Altadis USA (10/8/13)
Viaje Late Harvest Estate Grown 2011 (12/18/12)
Viaje Late Harvest Hang Time (2013)
Viaje Secret Sauce (7/2/13)

89
1502 Ruby (1/29/13)
Alec Bradley American Sun Grown (11/28/12)
Asylum 13 6 x 80  (5/9/13)
Asylum 13 Authentic Corojo (7/5/13)
Asylum 13 Ogre (3/18/13)
CAO Right Coast (2/7/13)
Casa Fernandez Aganorsa Leaf Maduro (2/28/13)
La Gloria Cubana Sanson (12/24/12)
Le Navarre (1/28/13)
Oliva Serie V Maduro Especial 2012 (1/12/13)
Ortega Wild Bunch 2013 Gearhead Gary Crankshaft (10/24/13)
Padilla Connecticut (5/17/13)
Padron 1964 Anniversary – Draper’s 125 Anniversary Edition Natural (5/21/13)
Perla del Mar by J.C. Newman (2/22/13)
Punch Bareknuckle (9/22/13)
Rafaeli’s Maduro (12/9/12)
Saint Luis Rey SLR Gen² by Altadis USA
Sosa Underground (4/16/13)
Surrogates Animal Cracker by L’Atelier Imports (11/13/13)
Viaje Oro Reserva VOR No. 5 (1/12/13)

88
CAO Brazilia Carnivale (4/24/13)
Camacho Liberty 2013 (11/11/13)
La Gloria Cubana Piramide Supra (2/18/13)
Headley Grange by Crowned Heads (11/24/12)
Kristoff Kristania (2/4/13)
Nestor Miranda 70th LE Nicaragua (4/19/13)
Ortega Serie “D” Maduro Lancero (4/9/13)
Ortega Wild Bunch 2013 Tony the Boss – Enforcer (5/13/13)
Rocky Patel Private Cellar (11/25/12)
Rocky Patel TAA Signature Series (4/8/13)
Viaje Satori 2013 (9/29/13)
Viaje Super Shot 2013 Corojo 10 Gauge (2/11/13)
Viaje White Label Project (WLP) Stuffed Turkey 2012 White Meat (12/12/12)

87
Chess Extreme Maduro (4/4/13)
Gold Strike by Royal Gold Cigars (9/2/13)
Toscanello Speciale (8/7/13)

86
Xikar HC Habano2

Note: Since we implemented scoring on 1/1/12 (and the cigar year already was in progress), we only have scores from 1/1/12.

97
Tatuaje Cabaiguan WCD 120 Redux (2/25/12)

95
262 Paradigm Lancero (1/14/12)
E.P. Carrillo Short Run 2010 No. 4 (1/11/12)
Illusione Singulare 2012 (7/30/12)
Jaime Garcia Reserva Especial Limited Edition 2011 Maduro (5/14/12)
La Palina El Diario KB (3/6/12)
Liga Privada Unico Serie UF-4 (7/12/12)
Tatuaje Little Boris (9/26/12)
Tatuaje Mummy (10/29/12)
Undercrown Corona ¡Viva! (5/18/12)
Viaje Friends and Family (3/25/12)

94
Boris 11 Connecticut (6/4/12)
CLE Corojo (8/29/12)
CyB by Joya de Nicaragua (Cuenca y Blanco)  (8/22/12)
E.P. Carrillo Cardinal Maduro (11/16/12)
E.P. Carrillo Edicion Inaugural 2009 (3/18/12)
La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor Reserva (11/5/12)
La Palina Collection – Goldie Laguito No. 2 (7/13/12)
Liga Privada Unico Serie Ratzilla (7/19/12)
Montecristo New York Connoisseur Edition (4/20/12)
Quesada Q D’Etat Daga (10/4/12)
Tatuaje Cojonu 2012 Habano (8/17/12)
Tatuaje Mini Mum (7/25/12)
Viaje Platino Reserva VPR No. 6 (3/4/12)
Viaje Summerfest 2012 Robusto (6/29/12)

93
262 Revere (11/17/12)
Alec Bradley Fine and Rare 2012 (11/7/12)
CAO Concert (10/25/12)
E.P. Carrillo Cardinal Natural (11/18/12)
Fonseca CXX Anni Corona (7/4/12)
La Flor Dominicana Limitado V (11/4/12)
Liga Privada No. 9 (2/4/12)
Litto Gomez Small Batch No. 3 (1/23/12)
Lou Rodriguez Edicion Premier (4/22/12)
Merlion by La Sirena (7/29/12)
Montecristo Epic Vintage 2007 (9/16/12)
My Father Atlantic Cigar Company 15th Anniversary (3/5/12)
My Father Commemorative 911 by Jaime Garcia Blend 343 10th Anniversary Oscuro (4/23/12)
My Father Le Bijou 1922 Federal Cigar 91st Cervantes Connecticut Shade (2/5/12)
My Father Le Bijou 1922 Ecuadorian Connecticut Federal Cigar Edition Corona (6/18/12)
My Father Le Bijou 1922 Ecuadorian Connecticut Federal Cigar Edition Petite Robusto (6/30/12)
Nat Sherman Timeless Collection (3/30/12)
Oliva Serie V Maduro 2011 (1/27/12)
Oliva Serie V Melanio (9/7/12)
Pinolero by A.J. Fernandez (10/17/12)
Tatuaje Cabaiguan Guapo Natural (2/15/12)
Tatuaje Cojonu 2012 Capa Especial (4/19/12)
Tatuaje – The Face (1/31/12)
Tatuaje Fausto (3/27/12)
Tatuaje Private Reserve (Black Label) Petit Lancero (6/19/12)
Tatuaje TAA 2012
VegaFina Sumum Edicion Especial 2010  (2/17/12)

92
Anoranzas by Miami Cigar and Company (11/21/12)
Avo Limited Edition 2012 La Trompeta (4/8/12)
Brick House Mighty Mighty Maduro by JC Newman (8/14/12)
CAO La Traviata Maduro (2/27/12)
CLE Connecticut (9/28/12)
El Tiante Habano Oscuro (4/13/12)
Emilio Draig K (7/29/12)
Flor de las Antillas by My Father Cigars (5/14/12)
Flores y Rodriguez Cabinet Selecction Capa Habano by PDR Cigars (7/9/12)
Foundry by General Cigar (11/8/12)
Iconic Leaf Recluse (10/28/12)
Jaime Garcia Reserva Especial New England Edition (4/18/12)
La Gloria Cubana Trunk Show Twenty Twelve Liga LR-1 (11/10/12)
La Palina Classic (9/22/12)
Liga Privada Unico Serie Feral Flying Pig (2/4/12)
Nestor Miranda Grand Reserve 2012 (10/6/12)
Quesada Q D’Etat Howitzer (6/21/12)
Rocky Patel Burn Naples, Florida (10/10/12)
Rocky Patel Freedom (10/18/12)
Rocky Patel Vintage 2003 Cameroon (9/12/12)
Rodrigo La Fortaleza Cinco 5 (7/5/12)
Tatuaje Frank Jr. (8/11/12)
Tatuaje Petite Cazadores Reserva (1/26/12)
Torano Master Maduro (9/25/12)
Viaje Holiday Blend 2011 (3/10/12)
Viaje Super Shot 10 Gauge (3/1/12)

91
1502 Emerald (11/19/12)
Aging Room Quattro F55 (9/29/12)
Casa Fernandez Copacabana (1/6/12)
Cohiba Edicion Diamante 2012 (10/13/12)
E.P. Carrillo Inch Natural (10/21/12)
Emilio AF Suave (8/23/12)
Excentrico by Elogio (9/11/12)
Gran Habano STK Zulu Zulu Ecuadorian Connecticut (Blue Box) (2/22/12)
Illusione Singulare 2011 (8/1/12)
La Duena by My Father Cigars (8/17/12)
La Gloria Cubana Trunk Show Twenty Twelve Liga YG-23 (11/9/12)
Liga Privada Unico Serie L40 Lancero (9/30/12)
Man O War Side Project Little Devil (9/27/12)
My Father Commemorative 911 by Jaime Garcia Blend 343 10th Anniversary Rosado (3/17/12)
My Father Commemorative 911 Limited Edition 2012 Connecticut Ecuador (10/14/12)
My Uzi Weighs a Ton +11 (8/24/12)
Nestor Miranda Special Selection Connecticut (8/18/12)

Oliva Serie V No. 4 (1/7/12)
Para Japon by La Aurora (2/20/12)
Partagas 1845 Heritage Rewrapped (4/27/12)
Perdomo Reserve Limited Edition Cameroon (2011 Re-Release) (3/11/12)
Pinar Del Rio Small Batch Reserve Habano (7/20/12)
Pinar Del Rio Small Batch Reserve Maduro (5/31/12)
Quesada Oktoberfest 2011 (11/22/12)
Rocky Patel Decade Edicion Limitada 2012 (6/25/12)
Rocky Patel Winter Collection 2012 (1/16/12)
Romeo by Romeo y Julieta (6/19/12)
Room 101 LTD OSOK (2/19/12)
Tatuaje Baby Face (7/16/12)
Tatuaje Cojonu 2012 Reserva (4/17/12)
Tatuaje 7th Capa Especial  (2/12/12)
Tatuaje Mexican Experiment (6/12/12)
Tatuaje Wolfie (7/21/12)
Tres Reynas (10/3/12)
VegaFina Jose Seijas 2011 (9/19/12)
Viaje C-4 (3/30/12)
Viaje Honey and Hand Grenades (9/8/12)
Viaje Oro Collector’s Edition (9/6/12)

90
Aging Room Havao Connecticut  (6/11/12)
Avo 25th Anniversary Edition (11/6/12)
Camacho Liberty 2012 (8/19/12)
Davidoff Limited Edition 2011 White Edition (3/15/12)
Davidoff White Edition 2012 (9/5/12)
Don Pepin Garcia Blue Label Firecracker (3/12/12)
E.P. Carrillo Inch Maduro (11/14/12)
Gurkha Ghost (11/22/12)
Gurkha Royal Challenge (3/18/12)
La Aurora Cien Anos  (7/24/12)
La Aurora Puro Vintage 2004 (4/10/12 – Reassessment)
Lou Rodriguez Edicion Reserva Connecticut (4/22/12)
My Uzi Weighs a Ton Bait Fish (1/13/12)
Ortega Serie “D” No. 6 (4/4/12)
Perdomo 20th Anniversary Sun Grown (11/30/12)
Quesada Jalapa (10/23/12)
Quesada Q D’Etat Molotov (2/27/12)
Room 101 San Andres (7/10/12)
Rocky Patel Autumn Collection 2009 (1/12/12)
Rocky Patel Edge Habano (11/13/12)
Senor Solomon Natural  (4/7/12)
Solaris by Arturo Fuente (11/3/12)
Sosa Family Selection Connecticut (3/23/12)
Surrogates Tramp Stamp (11/20/12)
Tatuaje Avion 12 (8/21/12)
Tatuaje Havana VI (Tatuaje Red Label) (2/10/12)
Tatuaje L′Esprit de Verite 2008 (1/29/12)
Tatuaje Lil’ Drac (6/27/12)
Trinidad Paradox by Altadis (10/26/12)
VegaFina Fortaleza 2 by Altadis (10/9/12)
Viaje Skull and Bones FOAB (3/16/12)
Viaje Skull and Bones M?stery BP 2012 Maduro (11/2/12)
Viaje White Label Project (WLP) Winter Classic (3/7/12)

89
Alec Bradley Connecticut (10/27/12)
Avo 80th (Avo Limited Edition 2006) (5/3/12)
Burn Special Reserve by Rocky Patel (5/21/12)
CAO Last Stick Standing (LSS): “A” (5/5/12)
CAO Last Sticking Standing (LSS): “C” (5/2/12)
CLE Cuarenta (7/14/12)
El Tiante Habano Rosado (4/5/12)
El Triunfador (Original Blend) (2/12/12)
Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur Dark Knight (2/26/12)
La Aurora 1495 Series (1/18/12)
Litto Gomez Small Batch No. 4 (2/6/12)
Litto Gomez Small Batch No. 4 Oscuro (8/15/12)
Macanudo 1968 (1/17/12)
Nestor Miranda Grand Reserve (2/20/12)
Oliva Serie V Maduro 2010 (1/20/12)
PDR 1878 Cubano Especial Capa Natural (9/23/12)
Perdomo Exhibicion Exhibit Maduro (2/16/12)
Pinar Del Rio Liga Especial Reserva Superior  (10/11/12)
Rocky Patel Hercules (6/17/12)
San Lotano Oval (Petit Robusto) (3/27/12)
Tatuaje 7th Reserva (3/9/12)
Te-Amo Revolution (10/22/12)
Torano Salutem (10/30/12)
Viaje 5th Anniversary (9/10/12)
Viaje White Label Project (WLP) St. Patrick’s Day Candela 2012 (3/14/12)

88
Alec Bradley Prensado (1/9/12)
Avo Lounge (3/11/12)
C & C Connecticut (4/6/12)
C & C Corojo (5/25/12)
CAO Last Stick Standing (LSS): “O” (5/7/12)
Chinnock Cellars Private Reserve (1/21/12)
Illusione Ultra OP No. 9 (6/8/12)
J. Grotto Series (5/12/12)
Jaime Garcia Reserva Especial TAA Edition (2/3/12)
La Aurora 107 (2/9/12)
La Flor Dominicana Double Claro (2/24/12)
Macanudo Cafe Gigante (4/21/12)
My Father Lounge Exclusive (7/28/12)
Ortega Serie “D” Natural (10/20/12)
Padron Family Reserve 85th Natural (4/11/12)
Perdomo 20th Anniversary Maduro (11/15/12)
Perdomo Exhibicion Exhibit Sun Grown (2/13/12)
Punch Rare Corojo 10th Anniversary (4/10/12)
Rocky Patel Summer Collection 2008 (2/7/12)
Sosa Family Selection Maduro (5/23/12)
Tatuaje Avion 11 (9/9/12)
Viaje Fifty Fifty Black (1/25/12)
Xikar HC Colorado Habano (1/22/12)

87
Casa Fernandez Miami Reserva (1/5/12)
Crowned Heads Four Kicks Seleccion No. 5 (6/26/12)
La Aurora Puro Vintage 2004 (1/24/12 – Initial Assessment)
Pedro Martin Platinum Series “M” (4/15/12)
Viaje Exclusivo Robusto 2012 (5/13/12)

86
La Flor Dominicana Air Bender Maduro (1/30/12)
Liga Privada Unico Serie “A” (3/2/12)
NHC Surrogates (1/19/12)
Tatuaje HCS (1/10/12)
Viaje Fifty Fifty Red (1/25/12)

83
Viaje WMD 2012 (3/21/12)